
Two years ago my husband and I were referred to a fertility clinic by a specialist who focuses on male fertility issues. At the time the use of a clinic wasn't on our radar; however, since the doctor made the suggestion we took the next step.
If this hadn't happened I wonder how long it would have taken us to make the conclusion that we should go to a clinic? Would we have taken that decision at all?
When you take part in fertility clinic programmes there are many questions that come up. Some of them come to mind during the process. Many crop up long after the procedures have been concluded. When you are in the midst of making decisions about your options, objectivity isn't always possible. Your desire to have a child is so strong that you can adjust your assessment of a situation according to the desired outcome.
Now that my clinic experience has ended, I'm realizing more and more how many questions one could face during the process. It was only after I thought about three women I know who were adopted that I realized that the benefit of these questions has to be
focussed on the feelings the resulting child will have about how he/she came into the world.
The first stage of options in fertility clinics is the use of
artificial insemination. With this procedure the
sperm is collected and inserted into the woman. If no drugs are used, the process is like an assisted version of normal reproductive practice. A pregnancy may or may not occur. When I asked about the statistics for this procedure the positive results were very low. I can't recall the exact statistics but I recall thinking "gosh that's an almost non-existent possibility". Not surprisingly, after several attempts nothing happened for us. If a child were to be the result of this procedure the parents would not need to divulge this information - if they so choose - to the child.
Does it really make a significant difference if they were conceived in a bed or with some assistance in this fashion? The details of that moment are really not one that most parents would discuss at any rate. So successful couples would feel no pressure to reveal the information to the child or anyone for that matter.
When AI doesn't work the next step is
AI with drugs. This is where the options become trickier. When drugs are taken, the clinic will not proceed with AI if in excess of a certain number of eggs are produced. If they do there is a high possibility of multiple births. While the details have not been forthcoming, this appears to be what happened in the famous "John and Kate" scenario. Still, even if your numbers are below the cutoff (I think it is about 4) there is still a possibility of multiples, including the possibility that one egg will divide. This pregnancy will bring about specific questions from members of the community.
Did you use fertility treatment? Why did you choose to selectively reduce some of the embryos? How will you support these children financially and otherwise? Going into the AI with drugs option, we may not ask these questions but we will have to face them if the results are positive.
If an AI with drugs preparation period results in an excessive amount of eggs the cycle can be converted immediately to an
IVF schedule. In this case the couple don't have too much time to think about
IVF. This was my experience. This is a hard situation because there are many questions that come out of the
IVF experience.
As the level of complexity increases with
IVF so does the complexity of the questions.
Do you really need to try IVF? Are you a good candidate? Are you financially able to afford IVF? If this IVF cycle doesn't work will you then commit to more? How many more can you afford financially and emotionally? Will your partner share your commitment to multiple IVF attempts? What will you do if you have more embryos than you need for implantation? Will you keep some for a future pregnancy? Will you give some up for scientific research? Do you feel that life has not begun at that point so you can therefore leave them for research purposes? Will you destroy them? (The same question about when life begins holds.) Will you make them available for adoption? Will it be an open or closed adoption? Does your clinic have an embryo adoption programme? Will you tell your family and friends that you have used IVF? Will you be able to support possible multiples? If you have multiples will you then have no need for the extra embryos? (This brings you back to the previous questions.) How will you explain to your child (will you?) that he/she was conceived using IVF? IVF has in the past been referred to as creating test tube babies. The procedure is becoming more accepted; however, it will be a long time before your child's beginning of life will be commonplace.
If you tell your child but not your family will the child have to keep a secret? Will you tell your child about any successful outcomes of adopted out embryos? Will your child be in contact with that other child (as a kind of open adoption)? Will that other child have the chance to meet your family?As you can imagine, most people do not go through all these mental scenarios. Once again, the perspective one takes can be clouded by one's desire to have a child. My thoughts on what would happen to extra embryos became very different after I went through the
IVF process. During
IVF you hang on every moment of conception and implantation. You wait to hear word about how the embryos are developing and dividing and you follow every stage of development through ultrasound and reading information online. Nowadays we know a lot more about reproduction than our mothers did. Not surprisingly you may come to the conclusion that life does begin at conception and you can't possibility conceive of anything other than embryo adoption for extra embryos. This is where you could hit a road block. If your clinic does not have an embryo adoption programme you will be responsible for shipping them elsewhere/finding a home for the embryos. This is not an easy task.
If you try one or more rounds of
IVF and you do not encounter success you will either stop your plans to start a family, look into adoption options or consider
egg/sperm donation, surrogacy or embryo adoption. Couples choose egg or sperm donation when one partner is unable to contribute to the development of the baby. They see this option as a way for at least one of the parents to be related to the child. Embryo adoption is considered desirable when a couple want to provide their own loving and healthy in utero environment for the child. (Something that is not always present when a child is in utero with a birth mother.) This connection continues through the process of birth and nursing. Surrogacy is seen as an option when a woman's womb cannot grow a baby, but the couple would like the child to be related to them. All of these options pose significant challenges to the normal expectations for conception and birth and must be seen as a form of adoption.
The questions that you would face in a regular adoption process apply here. They are also drastic departures from the normal biological patterns of the human race. Babies are conceived by two partnered people (usually loving partners) and are born in the same womb that conceived them. While egg/sperm donation, surrogacy and embryo adoption are common practice amongst the Hollywood set, the rest of the world is still somewhat uncomfortable simply with
IVF. If you doubt this claim, ask a woman who has twins these days how many prying questions she has had about whether there are twins in her family and whether she used
IVF. All the world's a reality TV show these days, it seems.
In one article I read on the issues surrounding egg donation, it was claimed that most clinics advise their patients to not tell their child about the donated egg. I was shocked by this information.
In 2010 if you adopted a child would you consider not telling your child that he/she is adopted?Listening to friends who were adopted talk about their experiences it is clear that human beings have a strong desire to know about their origins. They value the efforts and love of their adoptive parents, but they also want to know about their genetic roots - as far back as they can discover. This is one part of the adoption equation. They also care deeply about the reason for their adoption. Who were their parents? Why did they choose to give up their baby for adoption? The other concern is that they understand that the first nine months of their life in
utero were spent with another woman. Indeed surrogates have a legal right to keep the baby they have borne. For parents the strong desire to have a child reaches its conclusion when a child is born. During the child's youth questions surrounding the child's origin are not challenged. However when the child becomes an adult, if that person is not comfortable or satisfied with how these origins were explained, problems can ensue.
Here are a few challenges I have heard about from women who were adopted by non fertility procedures.
- my parents really shouldn't have adopted. They were 40 and too old to have children
- people in their late 30s have left it too late to have children
- I felt apart from the other siblings in my family who were not adopted
- I wanted to know about my biological family background. I found out that my biological mother had not told her family about my existence and did not want to introduce me to them
- If I have children I will not consider adopting as an option
Of course not all experiences with adoption are negative; however, you have to think about how you will educate your child about his/her roots.
Regarding egg/sperm donation, how will you explain to your child that half of their genetic make up comes from another person (likely unknown to the family)? Since the beginning of human history children have resulted from the union of a man and woman. Ideally they are in love (although not always). Egg donation breaks this anthropological reality.
How do you feel about this departure? How will you successfully explain your decisions and the decisions of the egg donor (who likely donated eggs for the money) to your child? How will the child feel about their connection to the biologically related parent compared to the non biologically parent? How will the non-related parent feel looking at the child knowing that the features not belonging to the spouse belong to another person and his/her family? Will the child want to know if he/she has siblings? Will it be possible to find out this information? Will it be possible to make contact? Will you explain the nature of your child's background to family or friends? If you do not make the information widely known, what will you say when friends talk about how the child resembles the non-related parent?If you choose to use a surrogate how will you explain this decision to the child/family and friends? How will you explain the reason the surrogate carried your child? How will you respond to criticism that you took your desire to have a biological child too far? Will you consider going to a country like India where poor women have children for others in order to make money? Do you feel this is an ethical practice?You may think that many of these questions are unnecessary. Consider that many of the girls adopted from China in the 1990s are now asking to meet their biological families. It is becoming clear that most of them were given up for adoption due to the one child policy, not because they were not wanted. A good number of them were caught up in human trafficking or were forcibly taken from their families. Human beings have a strong urge to understand their origins and how they came into this world. This reality is not only unavoidable but is a sensitive topic.
Also consider that even with natural procreation methods, children have many questions about the beginning of their life.
- If you and dad weren't in love any more why did you have a child?
- If you already had enough children, why didn't you use birth control?
- If you weren't married, why weren't you more careful/why didn't you use birth control?
- If I was a love child, did you only marry because I was going to be born?
We may not want to face these questions but the reality is that in the future our offspring will probably ask these questions of us. Knowing these questions won't stop us from engaging in fertility treatments. Keep in mind that when we join fertility groups or chat on fertility boards online, we are meeting people who are like minded and have similar goals. It is a good idea to have someone in our lives who is not a ready supporter of our decisions. Someone who can provide a healthy dose of scepticism. I have such a person in my life. His hard questions forced me to face up to the realities of the process in which I had engaged. As a result I feel that I have been more thorough and have taken better decisions that affect the future of other people's lives. It's not going to be a perfect response, but it's my best effort.
Couple sues sperm donorJudge rules surrogate mother may keep childMore women donating eggs in bad economyEmbryo adoption pros and cons
RETURN TO HOME PAGE